Modal Sandboxes vs Fly Machines for AI code sandboxes

Modal is a serverless compute platform used to run highly parallel workloads at scale. Sandboxes are a specific product in Modal that can be used to safely run untrusted, LLM-generated code. Fly.io is a distributed cloud VM platform used to deploy applications near end users.
Ramp
Quora
Substack
Cartesia
Cursor
Suno
Mistral AI
Contextual AI

What are Modal Sandboxes?

Modal is a serverless compute platform for running compute-intensive or highly parallel AI workloads in the cloud. Modal's proprietary container stack enables blazing fast cold starts for rapid developer iteration and production-grade scalability. Sandboxes are built on top of this container stack and are specifically used to define containers at runtime and safely run LLM-generated code. Like other Modal products, Sandboxes autoscale up and down from 0 to 10,000s of containers and are easily managed via Modal's simple SDK.

What are Fly Machines?

Fly.io is a distributed cloud VM platform for application deployments. Fly specializes in running applications close to where end users are. Unlike Modal's function-based serverless approach, Fly is primarily used for the deployment of application backends on stateful VMs. Fly Machines are VMs that can be managed via Fly's CLI or REST API. They are the compute primitive underlying Fly's app deployment product, but they can also be managed directly.

Performance and scalability

Modal LogoFly Logo

Enterprise-level scaling to 10,000+ sandboxes

CheckmarkCross

Proven network reliability at scale

CheckmarkCross

Sub-second container cold starts

CheckmarkCheckmark

Filesystem snapshotting for fast custom container creation

CheckmarkCross

Memory snapshotting for fast restores

CheckmarkCross

Multi-region support

CheckmarkCheckmark

White-glove engineering support to optimize your deployments

CheckmarkCross
Lovable Logo

Lovable uses Modal to power

millions of AI-generated apps

Lovable is the fastest-growing platform for creating AI-generated apps. They use Modal Sandboxes at massive scale to run LLM-generated code during user sessions.

"We've previously managed to break services like GitHub because of our load, so when Modal was able to handle the massive scale of our AI weekend event so smoothly, that meant a lot. We trust Modal to keep up with our growth in the long term."

Anton Osika, CEO and Founder at Lovable
Profile image

In a single weekend, Modal powered 250,000 user app creations for Lovable with no downtime. Not only that, Lovable reduced their sandbox orchestration code from 15,000 lines to 700 lines, ensuring long-term maintainability of this infrastructure.

Features

Modal LogoFly Logo

Run arbitrary LLM-generated code in an isolated environment

CheckmarkCheckmark

Support for custom images

CheckmarkCheckmark

Support for dynamic, runtime image builds per sandbox

CheckmarkCross

Data storage

CheckmarkCheckmark

Built-in sandbox state management

CheckmarkCross

Built-in tunnel feature for direct external connections to sandboxes

CheckmarkCross

Built-in distributed file system that can be attached to sandboxes

CheckmarkCross

First-party log collection and telemetry integrations

CheckmarkCross

Multi-region support

CheckmarkCheckmark

Persistent VMs

CrossCheckmark

Developer experience

Modal LogoFly Logo

Infrastructure defined in application code

CheckmarkCross

Python, JavaScript, Go SDKs

CheckmarkCross

Create sandboxes with one line of code

CheckmarkCross

No YAML or Dockerfiles needed

CheckmarkCross

Easy-to-use network control features

CheckmarkCross

Granular and intuitive observability features

CheckmarkCross

Environments

CheckmarkCross

Build a proof of concept in days, not months

CheckmarkCross

Security and enterprise readiness

Modal LogoFly Logo

SOC 2 Type II

CheckmarkCheckmark

HIPAA

CheckmarkCheckmark

Static IP proxies

CheckmarkCross

Granular control over outbound networking

CheckmarkCross

Choose Modal Sandboxes for:

Robust, reliable sandboxes at enterprise scale
Rich feature set specific for code sandboxes, including tunnels and state management
Streamlined developer experience that is code-first and low on infrastructure configuration

Choose Fly Machines for:

Stateful VMs for long-running processes in your application backend
Modal Logo